Component 3 Coursework: Comparative Essays

Learn it by playing

Answer these questions to earn energy, then fish and explore. No account needed.

For educators: ready-to-use lesson slides, revision notes for Component 3 Coursework: Comparative Essays (English, Literature) — use them in your lesson, or run the topic as an interactive class activity your learners play as a live game.

Lesson notes

What Component 3 Coursework Is

Component 3 is the coursework route through IGCSE Literature in English 0475; you take it instead of Paper 2 (Drama and Unseen).
You submit a portfolio of two essays: one Comparing texts essay (30 marks) and one Comparing poems essay (20 marks).
The whole component is worth 50 marks and counts for 50% of the qualification, alongside Paper 1.
It is set and marked internally by your centre, then externally moderated by Cambridge International.
The coursework route lets you apply all your literature skills without the pressure of an exam time limit.

The Comparing Texts Essay

You compare two complete texts; the advisory word count is approximately 1500 words.
One text must be drama; the second text may be drama or prose.
Both texts must be equivalent in scope and demand to the set texts for Paper 1 and Paper 2.
You may study plays from the Paper 2 set text lists, but you must not write about a set text you have studied for Paper 1.
The title must be phrased to allow scope for comparison and for assessing all four assessment objectives.

The Comparing Poems Essay

You compare two poems; the advisory word count is approximately 1000 words.
The poems should be equivalent in scope and demand to the poems studied for Paper 1.
You may write about set text poems you have studied for Paper 1.
As with the texts essay, the title must allow scope for comparison and coverage of all four assessment objectives.
If you use poetry or short stories, you must cover a minimum of two poems or short stories.

Word Count and Presentation

The advisory word count is approximately 1500 words for Comparing texts and approximately 1000 words for Comparing poems, including quotations but excluding references and a bibliography.
You may disadvantage yourself if your essays are significantly over or under the word count guidance.
Assignments must be written electronically, with the title typed in full at the top of each essay.
Each portfolio must include a completed Individual Candidate Record Card.
Proofread your work carefully before submitting.

The Four Assessment Objectives

AO1 — knowledge of the content of the text, through relevant detail including direct quotations from across the text.
AO2 — understanding of ideas, characters, situations and themes conveyed in the text, including implied or hidden meanings.
AO3 — analysis of how the writer creates meanings and achieves effects through form, language and structure.
AO4 — an informed personal response to the question and the text.
All four AOs are weighted equally (25% each) and are assessed holistically in each essay.

Comparison and Balance

There is no separate assessment objective for comparison, but you must address the task and meet the AOs through your comparison of the texts.
Unbalanced responses, where you comment at significantly greater length on one text or poem, are unlikely to reach the higher levels.
The top levels require you to sustain perceptive comparison with insight and individuality.
Comparison should run through the whole essay, not be bolted on at the end.

Critical and Empathic Tasks

A critical response asks you to explore and analyse the methods an author uses to achieve certain effects, often based on a theme.
An empathic response asks you to imagine you are a character and write as though you were that character at a particular moment in a prose or drama text.
Plot summary, character sketches, reviews and poetry comparison alone will not receive high marks.
Successful critical essays explore how writers make characters, themes and settings memorable and vivid.
Successful empathic essays place the author's created world at the centre of the response, with an authentic voice and a wide range of textual detail.

Writing Skills That Earn Marks

Embed quotations into your sentences rather than announcing them; avoid phrases like 'This is shown by the quote…'.
Support analysis with reasons, using words such as 'because', 'as' or 'since' to explain how language and structure achieve effects.
Avoid feature-spotting — listing techniques without analysis will not get you marks.
Avoid being narrative — you get no marks for just re-telling the story.
Include analysis of structure and form, especially important when considering a writer's use of dialogue.
Keep introductions and conclusions short and relevant; get straight to the point and don't repeat points already made.

Planning, Drafting and Authenticity

Start with active reading: annotate the text with your own comments and questions and explore beyond surface meanings.
Plan your responses, which can be done under teacher supervision; the emphasis is on a personal response and individual exploration.
You may use the internet or study guides to supplement your reading, but only to help you form your own conclusions.
After your first draft, discuss it with your teacher to develop points, integrate quotations, structure your argument and adjust word count.
Your teacher must not proofread, correct or mark your draft assignments; advice must stay at a general level.
Coursework must be your own, unaided work; taking someone else's work or ideas as your own is plagiarism, and inappropriate use of AI is treated as a form of plagiarism.

Slides

Step through every slide for this topic — plus flashcards and revision notes — with a free account.

Practice questions

Free preview — 8 of 57 questions. Sign up to see them all.

1.In the Component 3 Coursework portfolio, what must the Comparing texts essay compare?
Easy
- ATwo complete texts, one of which must be drama
- BTwo poems studied for Paper 1
- CA set text and an unseen extract
- DTwo extracts from the same novel
2.Which statement describes the length guidance for the two coursework essays?
Easy
- AAbout 1500 words for Comparing texts and about 1000 words for Comparing poems
- BAbout 1000 words for Comparing texts and about 1500 words for Comparing poems
- CAbout 600 words for each essay
- DAbout 1200 words for each essay
3.Which of these is an example title for the Comparing texts coursework essay given in the syllabus?
Medium
- ACompare how the writers convey the impact of social class in An Inspector Calls and The Importance of Being Earnest.
- BCompare how Ted Hughes uses animals to explore different ideas in The Jaguar and The Thought-Fox.
- CCompare the ways in which Alvi and Murray present older people in My Aunts Don't Want to Move and A Widower in the Country.
- DCompare how play is presented in Bouncing Boy (by Helen Dunmore) and from The Prelude (by William Wordsworth).
4.Which of the following are true of the Component 3 Coursework portfolio? (select all that apply)
Medium
- AIt is marked and internally moderated by the centre and externally moderated by Cambridge International.
- BThe Comparing texts essay is worth 30 marks and the Comparing poems essay is worth 20 marks.
- CThe Comparing texts essay may be written on a set text the candidate has studied for Paper 1.
- DUnbalanced responses that comment at much greater length on one text or poem are unlikely to reach the higher levels.
- EThe essays must be handwritten rather than produced electronically.
5.Which of the following are requirements for the Comparing texts essay? (select all that apply)
Medium
- AOne of the two texts must be drama.
- BThe second text may be prose or drama.
- CThe texts must be equivalent in scope and demand to the set texts for Paper 1 and Paper 2.
- DThe essay must be written on the same text as the Comparing poems essay.
- EBoth texts must be poems.
6.Which of the following are true about the Comparing poems essay? (select all that apply)
Medium
- AIt compares two poems.
- BThe poems may be ones studied for Paper 1.
- CIt is worth 20 marks.
- DIt is worth 30 marks.
- EThe poems should be equivalent in scope and demand to the poems studied for Paper 1.
7.The title of each coursework essay must be phrased to allow scope for comparison and for the assessment of all four assessment objectives.
Easy
True or false?
8.The title of each coursework essay must be typed in full at the top of the essay.
Easy
True or false?

Revision notes

## Component 3: Coursework — Comparative Essays **The route:** Paper 1 (Poetry and Prose) plus EITHER Paper 2 (Drama and Unseen) OR Component 3 Coursework. Component 3 is worth 50% of the qualification and 50 marks. **The portfolio: two essays** - **Comparing texts — 30 marks.** Two complete texts. One must be drama; the second may be prose or drama. Advisory word count ~1500 words. - **Comparing poems — 20 marks.** Two poems. Advisory word count ~1000 words. - Word counts include quotations but exclude references and bibliography. You may disadvantage yourself if significantly over or under the guidance. - Texts must be equivalent in scope and demand to the set texts for Paper 1 and Paper 2, and originally written in English. - For Comparing texts you must study two whole texts **not previously studied for Paper 1**. You may use plays from the Paper 2 set text lists. For Comparing poems you may write about set text poems studied for Paper 1. - Titles must be phrased to allow scope for comparison and for all four assessment objectives. Write the full title at the top of each essay. **The four AOs (each weighted 25%, assessed holistically — no fixed marks per AO)** - **AO1** Detailed knowledge of content, supported by reference to the text. - **AO2** Understand meanings and contexts; explore beyond surface meanings for deeper ideas and attitudes. - **AO3** Analyse how writers use language, structure and form to create meanings and achieve effects. - **AO4** Communicate a sensitive and informed personal response. There is **no separate AO for comparison**, but you must address the task and meet the AOs *through* your comparison. Unbalanced responses — much longer on one text or poem — are unlikely to reach the higher levels. **What examiners reward** - Perceptive comparison sustained with insight and individuality; detailed knowledge of **both** texts with well-selected reference interwoven seamlessly. - Critical understanding of both texts and their implications; insightful analysis of how writers achieve effects; evaluative personal engagement with the task. - Embed quotations into your sentences. Use "because", "as" or "since" to give reasons for effects. - Analyse structure and form, not just language. **What loses marks** - Plot summary, character sketches, reviews, or listing techniques without analysis ("feature-spotting"). - General topic sentences that make no specific point; empty phrases like "This is shown by the quote…". - Long introductions and conclusions; irrelevant background. "In this essay I shall discuss…" earns nothing. - Context should reinforce your interpretation, never replace it. **Process and rules** - Coursework is set and assessed internally, moderated externally. It must be your own unaided work; teachers may give brief general feedback but must not correct, edit or proofread drafts. Passing off others' work or ideas is plagiarism; inappropriate use of generative AI is treated as plagiarism. - Steps: choose texts and tasks with your teacher → plan → first draft → discussion → further unaided draft → proofread → final response with the title clearly at the top. - Start from active reading: annotate with your own comments and questions, and explore beyond surface meanings.

Component 3: Coursework: The optional coursework route (instead of Paper 2), worth 50% and 50 marks: a portfolio of two comparative essays — Comparing texts (30 marks) and Comparing poems (20 marks).
Comparing texts: An essay comparing two complete texts, ~1500 words, 30 marks. One text must be drama; the second may be prose or drama. Both must be texts not previously studied for Paper 1.
Comparing poems: An essay comparing two poems, ~1000 words, 20 marks. The poems may be set text poems studied for Paper 1.
AO1: Show detailed knowledge of the content of literary texts in the three main forms (drama, poetry and prose), supported by reference to the text.
AO2: Understand the meanings of literary texts and their contexts and explore texts beyond surface meanings to show deeper awareness of ideas and attitudes.
AO3: Analyse ways in which writers use language, structure and form to create meanings and achieve effects.
AO4: Communicate a sensitive and informed personal response to literary texts.
Personal response: Expressing what the text means to the candidate in response to the task; 'informed' means referring closely to the text in justifying these interpretations.
Unbalanced response: A response that comments at significantly greater length on one text or poem; unlikely to reach the higher levels of the assessment criteria.
Feature-spotting: Listing techniques a writer has used without analysis — this will not get you marks.
Plagiarism: Taking someone else's work or ideas and passing them off as your own. Inappropriate use of generative AI is treated as a form of plagiarism.

Flashcards

What are the two essays in the Component 3 Coursework portfolio?

1) Comparing texts — 30 marks, about 1500 words. 2) Comparing poems — 20 marks, about 1000 words.

How many marks is Component 3 Coursework worth in total, and what percentage of the qualification?

50 marks, worth 50% of the IGCSE. It is an alternative to Paper 2 (Drama and Unseen).

Which text types must the Comparing texts essay cover?

Two complete texts. One must be drama; the second may be drama or prose.

What is the advisory word count for the Comparing texts essay, and what happens if you are significantly over or under it?

About 1500 words, including quotations but excluding references and bibliography. Candidates may disadvantage themselves if significantly over or under this guidance.

What is the advisory word count for the Comparing poems essay?

About 1000 words, including quotations but excluding references and bibliography.

Which poems may you use for the Comparing poems essay?

Two poems of equivalent scope and demand to the Paper 1 poems. These may be poems you have studied for Paper 1.

Which texts are forbidden for the Comparing texts essay?

You must study two whole texts not previously studied for Paper 1. You may study plays from the Paper 2 set text lists.

How must the title of each coursework essay be phrased?

It must allow scope for comparison and for the assessment of all four assessment objectives.

Who sets, marks and moderates Component 3 Coursework?

It is set and assessed internally by your centre, then moderated externally by Cambridge International.

What does 'informed personal response' mean in this component?

'Personal response' means expressing what the text means to you in response to the task; 'informed' means referring closely to the text to justify your interpretations.

What is a critical coursework response?

An essay exploring and analysing the methods an author has used to achieve certain effects, often based on a theme.

What is an empathic coursework response?

An essay where you imagine you are a character in a prose or drama text and write your thoughts as that character at a particular moment.

Which four things will NOT receive high marks in coursework?

Plot summaries, character sketches, reviews of plays or novels, and poetry comparison (as a mere exercise rather than analysis).

What should be at the centre of a successful empathic essay?

The author's created world. The best responses combine a compellingly authentic 'voice' for the character with a wide range of detail from the text.

What does AO1 require in coursework?

Detailed knowledge of the text, shown through well-selected, well-integrated quotations and indirect references to the text.

What does AO2 require in coursework?

Going beyond surface meaning and plot to explore underlying ideas and attitudes — the writer's and your own — asking why the author made the choices they did.

What does AO3 require in coursework?

Critical engagement with how the text works: analysing how language, structure and form create meanings and effects. It is not just listing literary techniques.

What does AO4 require in coursework?

Shaping your writing to communicate your engagement with the text, directly addressing the key words in the question (such as 'powerful', 'vivid', 'striking', 'memorable', 'moving').

How are the four assessment objectives weighted in each coursework assignment?

All four assessment objectives are assessed equally and holistically; no fixed number of marks is awarded for any one objective.

Why is 'feature-spotting' penalised in coursework?

Listing techniques a writer has used without analysis will not get you marks. You must explain how the choices achieve particular effects.

How should quotations be used in a critical essay?

Embed them into your sentences and use them to spotlight a particular word or phrase, then comment on how the writer achieves effects. Avoid phrases like 'This is shown by the quote...'.

Which words can help you offer reasons for a writer's effects?

Use 'because', 'as' or 'since' to explain how the writer's choices of language and structure achieve the effects you mention.

What should be avoided in introductions and conclusions?

Overly long introductions and conclusions. Get straight to the point; avoid openings like 'In this essay I shall discuss two poems...' which receive no marks.

What should a coursework conclusion do?

Be relevant and summarise your personal response to the text and the task, focusing on the key words of the question — not just repeating points already made.

What is 'active reading' and why does it matter for coursework?

Annotating the text with your own comments and questions as you read, so you can explore beyond surface meanings to deeper ideas and themes.

What role should context play in a coursework essay?

Some appreciation of the context in which a text was written can help your understanding, but it should never be the main focus and should only be used if relevant to the question.

What are the rules on teacher help with coursework drafts?

You may discuss your work in general terms with your teacher, but the teacher must not proofread, correct or mark your draft assignments. Advice must stay at a general level so you lead the discussion.

How should coursework be presented for submission?

Written electronically, with the full title typed at the top of each essay. Each portfolio must include a completed Individual Candidate Record Card.

What is the top level for the Comparing texts essay and what does it require?

Level 6 (26–30 marks): sustains perceptive comparison with considerable insight and individuality, interweaving well-selected reference, critical understanding, insightful analysis and evaluative personal engagement.

What is the top level for the Comparing poems essay?

Level 4 (16–20 marks): sustains perceptive comparison with detailed knowledge, critical understanding, sensitive analysis of how poets achieve effects and a perceptive personal response.

Why are unbalanced responses penalised?

If you comment at significantly greater length on one text or poem, you are unlikely to reach the higher levels of the assessment criteria.

Is there a separate assessment objective for comparison?

No. There is no separate AO for comparison, but you must address the task and meet the assessment objectives through your comparison of the texts.

What is plagiarism in coursework and how is it treated?

Taking someone else's work or ideas and passing them off as your own. It must be cited and referenced properly; Cambridge International has systems to detect, investigate and address it.

How is the use of generative AI treated in coursework?

Inappropriate use of AI is treated as a form of plagiarism, under Cambridge International's policy on generative AI in coursework.

Unlock all 57 questions, flashcards & more

Create a free account to see every question, the slides, flashcards and revision notes for this topic.

Past papers

Past-paper practice for this topic is coming soon.

Coming soon